Latest Updates

First Step Act Time Credits in 2026: Supreme Court Review, BOP Rules & Federal Sentencing Updates

October 5–9, 2026 federal update covering First Step Act time credits, Supreme Court cases, BOP implementation, Guideline amendments, sentencing errors, supervised release, and post-conviction review.

First Step Act Time Credits and the New Supreme Court Term

First Step Act time credits remain an important issue for federal prisoners as the Supreme Court begins its 2026–2027 Term and the Bureau of Prisons continues updating how earned credits, programming, and prerelease placement are administered.

At the same time, federal appellate courts continue to address sentencing errors, Guideline calculations, supervised-release issues, jury instructions, and the procedural limits that often determine whether post-conviction relief remains available.

For defendants and families, these developments reinforce an important point: federal criminal law does not stop changing simply because a sentence was imposed years ago.

A new appellate decision may clarify how a Guideline should have been applied. A Supreme Court case may change the interpretation of a statute or constitutional rule. A Bureau of Prisons policy change may affect programming, earned-time credits, or prerelease planning.

But that does not mean every new decision creates a new basis for relief.

In older federal cases especially, the first questions are often procedural: What has already been raised? What has already been decided? Is the issue still legally available? And does the record contain facts that make a new development relevant to this particular defendant?

Federal Relief Consideration: The better approach is to begin with the record and then compare new decisions, Guideline amendments, BOP policies, and other developments against what actually happened in the individual case.

This update is provided for educational and informational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create legal representation.

Supreme Court Watch

November Will Bring Three Cases Important to Federal Prisoners

The Supreme Court has released its November argument calendar, and several cases may be especially important to federal prisoners, their families, and those involved in post-conviction litigation.

The November session begins on November 2, 2026 and includes cases involving First Step Act time credits, successive habeas petitions, and constitutional claims against federal prison officials.

Maxwell v. Dinis — First Step Act Credits and Habeas Relief

The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear Maxwell v. Dinis on November 2.

The case asks whether a federal prisoner may use a habeas petition to challenge the application of First Step Act earned time credits when the relief sought is accelerated transfer to prerelease custody, such as a halfway house or home confinement.

This is an important procedural question because First Step Act litigation does not always involve an earlier expiration of the prisoner’s sentence.

In many cases, the dispute concerns whether earned credits should move the prisoner into prerelease custody sooner.

The Supreme Court will decide whether habeas is an available procedural vehicle for that type of claim.

The case has drawn briefing from organizations including the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, FAMM, and habeas scholars.

Federal Relief Consideration: For federal prisoners, Maxwell may be important not only because of the underlying First Step Act dispute, but because the Court may determine whether federal courts can hear certain credit-related claims through habeas at all.

Guerrero v. Johnson — Successive Habeas Petitions

On November 4, the Supreme Court is scheduled to hear Guerrero v. Johnson.

The case involves a death-row prisoner who argues that he is intellectually disabled and therefore constitutionally ineligible for execution.

The procedural dispute is whether the claim could have been raised in an earlier federal habeas proceeding.

Federal law imposes strict limits on second or successive habeas petitions, with only narrow exceptions allowing a prisoner to return to federal court with a new claim after an earlier petition has already been litigated.

Although Guerrero arises in the death-penalty context, the Court’s treatment of successive-petition rules may be significant more broadly in federal post-conviction practice.

Federal Relief Consideration: Successive-petition rules often become important when prisoners discover new evidence, rely on later Supreme Court decisions, or argue that an earlier proceeding did not provide a meaningful opportunity to present a claim.

Nielsen v. Watanabe — Can a Federal Prisoner Sue BOP Officials?

The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear Nielsen v. Watanabe on November 9.

Kekai Watanabe alleges that federal prison officials failed to obtain appropriate medical treatment after he suffered a serious injury while incarcerated.

His lawsuit relies on Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents, the Supreme Court’s 1971 decision permitting damages claims against federal officials for certain constitutional violations.

In the decades since Bivens, however, the Supreme Court has significantly restricted the circumstances in which such claims may proceed.

The question in Watanabe is whether the prisoner’s claim falls within an already recognized Bivens context or instead represents an impermissible extension of that remedy.

Federal Relief Consideration: The decision could affect whether individual BOP employees may be sued for damages when a prisoner alleges serious constitutional misconduct involving medical care.

BOP Transgender Policy Reaches the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court is also considering an emergency application involving a Bureau of Prisons policy governing medical treatment and accommodations for transgender prisoners.

The federal government filed the application on September 28, asking the Court to stay a lower-court order preventing the BOP from implementing portions of its 2026 policy.

The Chief Justice requested a response from the prisoners challenging the policy, and that response was filed on October 8.

The immediate dispute concerns medical treatment and accommodations, but the broader issue involves how much deference courts should give the Bureau of Prisons when the agency relies on institutional security and prison administration to justify a major policy change.

Federal Relief Consideration: The Supreme Court’s ruling on the emergency request will not necessarily resolve the ultimate legality of the policy. The immediate question is whether the BOP may enforce the policy while the underlying litigation continues.

BOP and First Step Act Watch

First Step Act Implementation Remains Under Scrutiny

The Bureau of Prisons continues to reorganize its First Step Act operations.

In September, BOP announced creation of a dedicated First Step Act office intended to focus on implementation of the Act, including earned time credits, evidence-based programming, and prerelease placement.

The Bureau has also revised its First Step Act time-credit regulations.

An interim final rule amended 28 C.F.R. § 523.42 and addressed when eligible prisoners may begin earning credits and how those credits are calculated and applied.

Under the current rule, eligible prisoners generally earn 10 days of First Step Act time credits for every 30 days of successful participation in qualifying evidence-based recidivism-reduction programs or productive activities.

Minimum- and low-risk prisoners who satisfy additional requirements may earn an additional five days per 30-day period.

APEX Practice Point: First Step Act disputes increasingly involve more than whether credits have been earned.

Important questions may include when credits began accruing, whether particular programming qualifies, whether credits were correctly calculated, and whether they should be applied toward prerelease custody or supervised release.

That makes the Bureau’s records especially important.

Prisoners disputing First Step Act calculations should preserve copies of:

  • First Step Act time-credit worksheets
  • PATTERN assessments
  • Program participation records
  • Administrative remedies
  • Projected release dates
  • Notices showing how BOP calculated or applied credits

Those records may become important if administrative review fails and court intervention becomes necessary.

BOP Labor Dispute Raises Operational Concerns

A federal labor dispute involving the Bureau of Prisons escalated this week when the union representing approximately 30,000 BOP employees asked a federal judge to hold the agency in contempt.

On September 29, U.S. District Judge Vernon D. Oliver of the District of Connecticut granted a preliminary injunction requiring the Bureau of Prisons to restore its collective-bargaining agreement with the National Council of Prison Locals, Council 33.

The dispute grew out of BOP Director William K. Marshall III’s September 2025 decision to terminate the agreement.

On October 6, the union returned to court and alleged that BOP had not complied with the injunction.

According to the contempt motion, the Bureau had failed to restore union office space, official union time, representation in disciplinary proceedings, and other rights that existed under the agreement.

Why This Matters to Federal Prisoners: The litigation concerns BOP employees rather than inmate rights directly, but staffing and labor relations can affect institutional operations.

Staff shortages, overtime demands, employee morale, disciplinary procedures, movement within institutions, programming availability, visiting, medical services, transfers, and prerelease processing can all be affected when relations between management and correctional employees deteriorate.

Federal Circuit Court Watch

Tenth Circuit — Kidnapping Convictions Reversed and Other Convictions Vacated

The Tenth Circuit issued a significant defendant-favorable decision on October 6 in United States v. Wahhaj, a consolidated appeal arising from a federal prosecution in New Mexico.

Several defendants were convicted after a joint trial involving kidnapping, material-support, and conspiracy charges, and all four defendants received life sentences.

On appeal, the Tenth Circuit reversed or vacated several convictions.

The first major issue involved the federal kidnapping statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1201.

The statute requires the Government to prove that a defendant “unlawfully” seized, confined, kidnapped, abducted, or carried away another person.

The district court instructed the jury that the kidnapping was unlawful if the child was taken or held against the wishes of his mother.

The Tenth Circuit held that the instruction misstated the law.

The court explained that “unlawfully” is an independent element of the federal kidnapping statute and that the Government therefore had to prove that the defendants’ conduct was contrary to law or otherwise legally unauthorized.

The court further concluded that the Government had failed to introduce sufficient evidence establishing that element.

Because the reversal rested on insufficient evidence rather than only an erroneous jury instruction, the defendants whose kidnapping convictions were reversed may not be retried on those charges.

The opinion also addressed a Sixth Amendment issue involving two defendants who represented themselves at trial.

The district court excluded those defendants from a conference involving jury notes while allowing standby counsel to participate.

The Tenth Circuit held that exclusion violated the defendants’ constitutional right of self-representation.

Because the conference involved matters of tactical importance, the court classified the violation as structural error and vacated the affected convictions.

Federal Relief Consideration: Wahhaj reinforces the importance of examining statutory elements, sufficiency of the evidence, jury instructions, and constitutional trial rights.

Eleventh Circuit — Later Guideline Amendment Requires Resentencing

On October 8, the Eleventh Circuit vacated Antonio Brown’s sentence and remanded for resentencing after concluding that a later Sentencing Guideline amendment showed that a two-level robbery enhancement had been improperly applied.

Brown had pleaded guilty to Hobbs Act robbery and firearm charges arising from two armed robberies.

At sentencing, Brown received a two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G. § 2B3.1(b)(4)(B) for physically restraining the victims.

At the time, Eleventh Circuit precedent interpreted that enhancement broadly.

The Sentencing Commission later amended § 2B3.1(b)(4)(B).

The amended Guideline now requires that a victim’s freedom of movement be restricted through physical contact or confinement, such as being tied, bound, or locked up.

Brown pointed firearms at the victims and ordered them to lie down, but there was no evidence that he tied, bound, locked up, or physically confined them in the manner contemplated by the amended Guideline.

The Eleventh Circuit concluded that the 2025 amendment was clarifying rather than substantive and therefore could be applied to Brown’s pending direct appeal.

The court found plain error and prejudice because the enhancement increased Brown’s Guidelines range.

Federal Relief Consideration: A later Sentencing Guideline amendment may sometimes matter even when it is not generally listed as retroactive under U.S.S.G. § 1B1.10(d), particularly when the amendment is treated as clarifying and the case remains pending on direct appeal.

Sixth Circuit — A Reasonable Sentence Can Still Rest on Reversible Error

The Sixth Circuit’s decision in United States v. Mohamed, No. 26-3017, provides another important lesson about sentencing error.

Mohamed was serving a term of supervised release when he left the United States and traveled to Canada without permission.

Years later, he returned to the United States and was convicted of aggravated illegal reentry.

At his revocation proceeding, the district court treated that later reentry conviction as an additional supervised-release violation.

Doing so increased the applicable revocation range from 3–9 months to 4–10 months.

The Supreme Court later held in Rico v. United States that supervised release does not automatically stop running when a defendant absconds.

That meant Mohamed’s supervised-release term had expired before his later illegal-reentry offense occurred.

The later conviction therefore was not a supervised-release violation.

The Government argued that the error was harmless because Mohamed’s nine-month revocation sentence still fell within the lower 3–9 month range.

The Sixth Circuit disagreed and vacated the revocation sentence.

Federal Relief Consideration: A sentence does not become immune from reversal merely because the number ultimately imposed falls within another permissible range. The reviewing court must still be confident that the district judge would have imposed the same sentence without relying on the erroneous consideration.

Not Every Useful Guideline Amendment Has to Be Listed as Retroactive

One of the most important lessons from this week’s Eleventh Circuit decision in United States v. Brown is that defendants should not assume a later Sentencing Guideline amendment is irrelevant simply because it is not listed among the amendments made retroactive under U.S.S.G. § 1B1.10(d).

There is an important distinction between a substantive amendment and a clarifying amendment.

A substantive amendment changes the law.

A clarifying amendment explains what the Guideline meant in the first place.

That distinction mattered in Brown.

The Sentencing Commission amended the robbery Guideline governing physical restraint, U.S.S.G. § 2B3.1(b)(4)(B), to require restriction of a victim’s movement through physical contact or confinement.

The amendment was not listed in § 1B1.10(d) as an amendment generally available for sentence reductions under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(2).

But the Eleventh Circuit nevertheless held that the amendment could be applied to Brown’s pending direct appeal because it was clarifying rather than substantive.

That is a different form of retroactivity.

It does not mean that every already-sentenced prisoner can automatically file a § 3582(c)(2) motion based on the amendment.

Instead, in the right procedural posture, a court may use a later clarifying amendment to determine what an earlier version of the Guideline properly meant.

Why This Distinction Matters

When reviewing an older federal sentence, the analysis should not stop with:

“Was this amendment made retroactive by the Sentencing Commission?”

Other questions may include:

  • Was the amendment described as clarifying?
  • Did it resolve a circuit split?
  • Did it move language from Guideline commentary into the Guideline text?
  • Did it explain how an existing enhancement was always supposed to operate?
  • Was the defendant’s case still pending on direct appeal when the amendment took effect?
  • Did the amendment undermine circuit precedent used to calculate the original sentence?

Those questions may matter even when § 1B1.10 does not independently authorize a sentence-reduction motion.

The Procedural Vehicle Still Matters

The existence of a favorable amendment does not by itself create jurisdiction.

A prisoner still needs a valid procedural vehicle for obtaining relief.

For one defendant, that may be a pending direct appeal.

For another, it may be a properly authorized § 3582(c)(2) proceeding.

For someone else, the issue may arise in a § 2255 claim, resentencing proceeding, or another authorized form of post-conviction review.

Identifying a favorable Guideline change is therefore only the first step.

The next question is whether the defendant’s procedural posture permits a court to do anything with it.

Frequently Asked Questions About First Step Act Time Credits

What are First Step Act time credits?

First Step Act time credits may be earned by eligible federal prisoners through successful participation in qualifying evidence-based recidivism-reduction programs or productive activities.

How many First Step Act time credits can an eligible prisoner earn?

Under the rule discussed in this update, eligible prisoners generally earn 10 days of credits for every 30 days of successful participation in qualifying programs or activities.

Minimum- and low-risk prisoners who satisfy additional requirements may earn an additional five days per 30-day period.

Can First Step Act credits be used for halfway house or home confinement?

First Step Act disputes may involve whether earned credits should be applied toward prerelease custody, including transfer to a halfway house or home confinement.

The Supreme Court’s upcoming Maxwell v. Dinis case addresses whether habeas may be used to challenge the application of credits when accelerated prerelease custody is the relief sought.

What records should prisoners keep for a First Step Act credit dispute?

Prisoners should consider preserving time-credit worksheets, PATTERN assessments, program records, administrative remedies, projected release dates, and notices showing how BOP calculated or applied credits.

Does a new Guideline amendment automatically reduce an old sentence?

No. Whether an amendment can affect an existing sentence depends on the amendment, whether it is substantive or clarifying, whether it has been designated retroactive, and the procedural posture of the individual case.

What Is the APEX Free Quick Look?

Federal prisoners and their families often know that something may be wrong with a conviction, sentence, or Bureau of Prisons calculation, but they are not always sure whether the issue is legally significant or what type of relief may be available.

That is where the APEX Free Quick Look comes in.

The Free Quick Look is a preliminary review designed to identify whether a federal case may contain an issue worth examining more closely.

It is not a full written legal analysis, and it does not guarantee that relief is available.

Depending on the case, the review may consider potential issues involving:

  • Ineffective assistance of counsel
  • Federal sentencing errors
  • Guideline calculations
  • Compassionate release
  • First Step Act time credits
  • Changes in federal law
  • Supervised-release issues
  • Direct appeals
  • § 2255 proceedings
  • Other post-conviction concerns

For many prisoners, the most important first question is not:

“Can I win?”

The better first question is:

“Is there something here that deserves a closer look?”

What Should You Send?

Helpful information may include:

  • The prisoner’s full name and federal register number
  • The district court and case number
  • The sentence imposed and approximate sentencing date
  • The offense or offenses of conviction
  • Whether a direct appeal or § 2255 motion has already been filed
  • Any recent motions or court rulings
  • A short explanation of the issue believed to exist

Court orders, docket sheets, sentencing documents, appellate decisions, Presentence Reports, and other relevant records can also be helpful when available.

What Happens After the Quick Look?

If the preliminary review suggests that a potentially significant issue may exist, APEX may recommend a more detailed Federal Case Evaluation.

That deeper review can involve examining the procedural history, sentencing record, prior filings, applicable Guidelines, intervening changes in law, and possible procedural vehicles for relief.

Sometimes further investigation may be warranted.

Sometimes the conclusion may be that a particular issue is unlikely to provide relief.

Both answers can be useful because they may help prisoners and families avoid spending time and money pursuing claims that do not fit the law or procedural history.

There is no obligation to proceed beyond the Free Quick Look.

Federal Cases Should Be Reviewed From the Record Outward

This week’s developments all point to the same basic lesson: in federal criminal and post-conviction cases, the details matter.

A later Sentencing Guideline amendment can change the meaning of an enhancement. A supervised-release violation may disappear because of a later Supreme Court decision. A conviction may fail because the jury was instructed on the wrong legal standard. And a prisoner with a potentially valid claim may still lose if the wrong procedural vehicle is used.

That is why federal cases should be reviewed from the record outward.

The starting point is not simply the latest court decision or newest amendment.

The starting point is the defendant’s own case:

  • The indictment
  • The plea agreement
  • The Presentence Report
  • The sentencing transcript
  • The judgment
  • Prior motions
  • The appellate history
  • The specific legal rules applied

From there, later developments in the law can be compared against what actually happened.

For some prisoners, that comparison may reveal a meaningful issue.

For others, it may confirm that a particular change in law does not presently provide an avenue for relief.

Either way, careful review is better than guessing.

Related APEX Federal Relief Resources